On March 30, 2010 at 10:53, Neurad1 said...
I'd really like to hear a reply to the question of whether the cost of the RTI T2B (or other RTI remotes) can be justified to customers in the Logitech Harmony era? If so, how do you explain what makes the RTI worth the significantly greater cost?
If we are talking RF than you need to understand how Harmony RF works and RTI RF works. Harmony will spit out seperate RF commands that gets converted into seperate IR commands. So if one of those RF commands were missed so would the IR command. RTI uses a single RF trigger code so if the processor gets it than it will execute all subsequent IR commands. Reliablitiy!
Harmony is setup on toggle power commands and uses flags for everything. So if someone goes up to the receiver and presses the power button shutting the TV off and you grab the Harmony, press watch TV, it won't turn back on. You'll have to use the help feature. With RTI you setup the remote so every time the receiver turns on, the TV turns on, and so forth (based on equipment with discrete commands). So ultimately there is no need for a stupid help button which by the way you have to get up from your comfortable chair and open the cabinet door to visually see what's on or off.
Harmony's are junk. At some point the buttons will fall off. The are very cheap and will fall apart much quicker than a RTI remote. The only issue with RTI is there battery life but if you keep an extra battery around you shouldn't have an issues.
The web based programming isn't as flexible as RTI. Trying to control a zone 2 with Harmony is a nightmare!
RTI remotes can be apart of a system. The remotes are a control solution and not individual TV remotes.
RTI remotes are much more friendly to guests and babysitters. A guest won't know how to use the help feature on the Harmony if something goes wrong making the person much more frustrated and less likely to use it.
I equate it cars. There are many different cars and they can all get you from point A to point B. Hyundai's will get you where you want to go but you may need to fix things more often and they might break down sooner but they do the job. Consider RTI like a 3 or 5 series BMW. It's going to outperform the Hyundai in every catergory but in the end it will do the same thing. If you are comfortable driving a Hyundai then buy a Harmony and you'll be happy.
To sum it up, Harmony Sucks!