I like Sherlock (though like DEaniel said it bugs me each series is so short) and elementary as well

forever reminded me more of [Link: tv.com] than SherlockI like it enough to watch it but it also kind of bugs me a bit for two reasons

1) I get it the guy is immortal but do we really need him to die endlessly (for those that have not seen the show, when he dies the dead body disappears and he shows up in the nearest body of water alive again.)

2)why did they make him a coroner in NY? he is never in the coroner's office and we have to assume that somehow NY can't find a decent police officer to partner with the homicide detective so he is always out on the field working as her partner while his apprentice takes care of the dead.

Never been a fan of Murdoch Mysteries, to me it always just tried too hard and came off as cheesy because of it.